Just thinking aloud... Since the build uses net-snmp, it should use the same mibs net-snmp uses... So xymon will know about my SmartUPS and poweredge.

I'm gonna have to study the code some more

 On 5/16/19 10:08 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

Right you are. DOSNMP is set to "yes" as a result of SNMP being set to 1 (and the Net-SNMP tools being found).

On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 14:42, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> wrote:

On 5/16/19 9:10 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
> On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 13:36, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> wrote:
>
>     Yes, I did Jeremy.  My apologies.
>
>
> No problem.
>
>     I did figure out I have to export SNMP=1 then configure and rebuild
>
>
> Ah, I didn't know that. Or I forgot that.
>
> Just looking at the code now - are you sure this isn't "DOSNMP=1"?


The Makefile tests for if  $SNMP=1...  At least in 4.3.28


>     What is the tag in the hosts file (if any)?
>
>
> Nothing. The hostnames are found by xymon-snmpcollect in the snmphosts.cfg. You still need the hosts to be in hosts.cfg, but not tags are required.

> Jeremy

Thanks again!


>     On 5/16/19 6:41 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>     > If you meant to say, "Hey Jeremy" then the answer is, that it's all stuff for Xymon.
>     >
>     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 11:15, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> wrote:
>     >
>     >     Hey Josh, I saw that before.  Is that stuff that devmon looks at or stuff for xymon.
>     >
>     >     I'm not at all clear
>     >
>     >     Thanks in advance
>     >
>     >     On 5/16/19 6:00 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>     >>     Xymon already has code for SNMP that works, but isn't documented. I have it working for me, but it required a fair bit or digging to find the right
configuration. I've
>     >>     posted on this previously; might help: https://lists.xymon.com/archive/2019-March/046191.html
>     >>
>     >>     J
>     >>
>     >>     On Thu, 16 May 2019 at 19:26, Bruno Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>> wrote:
>     >>
>     >>         Thanks you Josh,
>     >>
>     >>         Yes I know about devmon (I put my own devmon version which is a try to be a consolidate version)
>     >>
>     >>         In fact, I just would like to know if there was another SNMP development (but it seems not as you say it will be merged) inside Xymon . (I am thinking a way to
>     integrate
>     >>         SNMP v3, but it do not uses the current SNMP_session perl lib as it is not supported within this lib)?
>     >>
>     >>         Regards
>     >>
>     >>         Bruno Manzoni
>     >>         (Bonomani)
>     >>
>     >>
>     >>         Le 14.05.2019 à 15:20, Josh Luthman a écrit :
>     >>>         You can just use Devmon these days.
>     >>>
>     >>>         I've seen nothing to suggest the projects will be merged.
>     >>>
>     >>>         Josh Luthman
>     >>>         Office: 937-552-2340
>     >>>         Direct: 937-552-2343
>     >>>         1100 Wayne St
>     >>>         Suite 1337
>     >>>         Troy, OH 45373
>     >>>
>     >>>
>     >>>         On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 12:33 PM Bruno Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>> wrote:
>     >>>
>     >>>             Hello,
>     >>>
>     >>>             Is there any plan to have SNMP include with a new version of xymon? If
>     >>>             yes, what is the current state?

Also, a xymond_client process needs to be fired up to parse the data coming from the SNMP collector:

[clientdata-snmp] ENVFILE /usr/lib/xymon/server/etc/xymonserver.cfg NEEDS xymond CMD xymond_channel --channel=client --log=$XYMONSERVERLOGS/clientdata-snmp.log xymond_client --collectors=snmpcollect

On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 15:45, Jeremy Laidman <jeremy at laidman.org> wrote:

Not sure what that will give you. The OIDs are extracted from the file snmpmibs.conf, and I expect you'll have to populate that with anything you want to monitor.

One thing I forgot to mention is that you need to create a task to run the xymon-snmpcollect program every 5 minutes. I created a tasks.d/xymon-snmpcollect.cfg file containing the following:

[snmpcollect] ENVFILE $XYMONHOME/etc/xymonserver.cfg CMD $XYMONHOME/ext/xymon-snmpcollect --debug LOGFILE $XYMONSERVERLOGS/xymon-snmpcollect.log INTERVAL 5m

Obviously the --debug flag can be removed.

On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 15:26, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org> wrote:

...

Just thinking aloud... Since the build uses net-snmp, it should use the same mibs net-snmp uses... So xymon will know about my SmartUPS and poweredge.

I'm gonna have to study the code some more

On 5/16/19 10:08 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

...

Right you are. DOSNMP is set to "yes" as a result of SNMP being set to 1 (and the Net-SNMP tools being found).

On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 14:42, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> wrote:

On 5/16/19 9:10 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
> On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 13:36, Bruce Ferrell <

bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto: bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> wrote: > > Yes, I did Jeremy. My apologies. > > > No problem. > > I did figure out I have to export SNMP=1 then configure and rebuild > > > Ah, I didn't know that. Or I forgot that. > > Just looking at the code now - are you sure this isn't "DOSNMP=1"?

The Makefile tests for if  $SNMP=1...  At least in 4.3.28


>     What is the tag in the hosts file (if any)?
>
>
> Nothing. The hostnames are found by xymon-snmpcollect in the

snmphosts.cfg. You still need the hosts to be in hosts.cfg, but not tags are required.

> Jeremy

Thanks again!


>     On 5/16/19 6:41 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>     > If you meant to say, "Hey Jeremy" then the answer is, that

it's all stuff for Xymon. > > > > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 11:15, Bruce Ferrell < bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto: bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> wrote: > > > > Hey Josh, I saw that before. Is that stuff that devmon looks at or stuff for xymon. > > > > I'm not at all clear > > > > Thanks in advance > > > > On 5/16/19 6:00 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: > >> Xymon already has code for SNMP that works, but isn't documented. I have it working for me, but it required a fair bit or digging to find the right configuration. I've > >> posted on this previously; might help: https://lists.xymon.com/archive/2019-March/046191.html > >> > >> J > >> > >> On Thu, 16 May 2019 at 19:26, Bruno Manzoni < bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> <mailto: bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> > <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto: bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>> wrote: > >> > >> Thanks you Josh, > >> > >> Yes I know about devmon (I put my own devmon version which is a try to be a consolidate version) > >> > >> In fact, I just would like to know if there was another SNMP development (but it seems not as you say it will be merged) inside Xymon . (I am thinking a way to > integrate > >> SNMP v3, but it do not uses the current SNMP_session perl lib as it is not supported within this lib)? > >> > >> Regards > >> > >> Bruno Manzoni > >> (Bonomani) > >> > >> > >> Le 14.05.2019 à 15:20, Josh Luthman a écrit : > >>> You can just use Devmon these days. > >>> > >>> I've seen nothing to suggest the projects will be merged. > >>> > >>> Josh Luthman > >>> Office: 937-552-2340 > >>> Direct: 937-552-2343 > >>> 1100 Wayne St > >>> Suite 1337 > >>> Troy, OH 45373 > >>> > >>> > >>> On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 12:33 PM Bruno Manzoni < bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> <mailto: bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> > <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto: bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>> wrote: > >>> > >>> Hello, > >>> > >>> Is there any plan to have SNMP include with a new version of xymon? If > >>> yes, what is the current state?

Other than documentation (obviously), would that be the primary feature set that helps makes this a reasonable thing to integrate in officially?

-jc

On 5/16/2019 11:08 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote:

I just figured out there has to be a task... At first I wondered how xymonnet launched xymon-snmpcollector, then I started running it by hand and running tcpdump to see what was being polled

What it looks like what we don't get is mib variable manipulation ala devmon... calculated load percentages etc.

Still I think a move in the right direction and it directly supports snmp v3

On 5/16/19 10:45 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

...

Not sure what that will give you. The OIDs are extracted from the file snmpmibs.conf, and I expect you'll have to populate that with anything you want to monitor.

One thing I forgot to mention is that you need to create a task to run the xymon-snmpcollect program every 5 minutes. I created a tasks.d/xymon-snmpcollect.cfg file containing the following:

[snmpcollect] ENVFILE $XYMONHOME/etc/xymonserver.cfg CMD $XYMONHOME/ext/xymon-snmpcollect --debug LOGFILE $XYMONSERVERLOGS/xymon-snmpcollect.log INTERVAL 5m

Obviously the --debug flag can be removed.

On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 15:26, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> wrote:

    Just thinking aloud... Since the build uses net-snmp, it should use the same mibs net-snmp uses... So xymon will know about my SmartUPS and poweredge.

    I'm gonna have to study the code some more

      On 5/16/19 10:08 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: > Right you are. DOSNMP is set to "yes" as a result of SNMP being set to 1 (and the Net-SNMP tools being found). > > > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 14:42, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> wrote: > >     On 5/16/19 9:10 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 13:36, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> wrote: >     > >     >     Yes, I did Jeremy.  My apologies. >     > >     > >     > No problem. >     > >     >     I did figure out I have to export SNMP=1 then configure and rebuild >     > >     > >     > Ah, I didn't know that. Or I forgot that. >     > >     > Just looking at the code now - are you sure this isn't "DOSNMP=1"? > > >     The Makefile tests for if  $SNMP=1...  At least in 4.3.28 > > >     >     What is the tag in the hosts file (if any)? >     > >     > >     > Nothing. The hostnames are found by xymon-snmpcollect in the snmphosts.cfg. You still need the hosts to be in hosts.cfg, but not tags are required. > >     > Jeremy > >     Thanks again! > > >     >     On 5/16/19 6:41 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >     >     > If you meant to say, "Hey Jeremy" then the answer is, that it's all stuff for Xymon. >     >     > >     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 11:15, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> >     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>> wrote: >     >     > >     >     >     Hey Josh, I saw that before.  Is that stuff that devmon looks at or stuff for xymon. >     >     > >     >     >     I'm not at all clear >     >     > >     >     >     Thanks in advance >     >     > >     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:00 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >     >     >>     Xymon already has code for SNMP that works, but isn't documented. I have it working for me, but it required a fair bit or digging to find the right >     configuration. I've >     >     >>     posted on this previously; might help: https://lists.xymon.com/archive/2019-March/046191.html >     >     >> >     >     >>     J >     >     >> >     >     >>     On Thu, 16 May 2019 at 19:26, Bruno Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >     >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>> wrote: >     >     >> >     >     >>         Thanks you Josh, >     >     >> >     >     >>         Yes I know about devmon (I put my own devmon version which is a try to be a consolidate version) >     >     >> >     >     >>         In fact, I just would like to know if there was another SNMP development (but it seems not as you say it will be merged) inside Xymon . (I am thinking a way to >     >     integrate >     >     >>         SNMP v3, but it do not uses the current SNMP_session perl lib as it is not supported within this lib)? >     >     >> >     >     >>         Regards >     >     >> >     >     >>         Bruno Manzoni >     >     >>         (Bonomani) >     >     >> >     >     >> >     >     >>         Le 14.05.2019 à 15:20, Josh Luthman a écrit : >     >     >>>         You can just use Devmon these days. >     >     >>> >     >     >>>         I've seen nothing to suggest the projects will be merged. >     >     >>> >     >     >>>         Josh Luthman >     >     >>>         Office: 937-552-2340 >     >     >>>         Direct: 937-552-2343 >     >     >>>         1100 Wayne St >     >     >>>         Suite 1337 >     >     >>>         Troy, OH 45373 >     >     >>> >     >     >>> >     >     >>>         On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 12:33 PM Bruno Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >     >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>> wrote: >     >     >>> >     >     >>>             Hello, >     >     >>> >     >     >>>             Is there any plan to have SNMP include with a new version of xymon? If >     >     >>>             yes, what is the current state? >

---

Xymon mailing list Xymon at xymon.com http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon

I'd have to say xymon integration is FAR more stable and flexible than devmon... And I've put a LOT of time into understanding devmon configuration.

Devmon is a "dancing bear" (it's not how well it dances, it's that it dances at all).

That said, because SNMP is so... rich? Charting configuration is interesting to think about.

On 5/17/19 2:04 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

For me, yes.

On Fri, 17 May 2019, 17:59 Japheth Cleaver, <cleaver at terabithia.org <mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org>> wrote:

Other than documentation (obviously), would that be the primary feature
set that helps makes this a reasonable thing to integrate in officially?

-jc

On 5/16/2019 11:08 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote:
> I just figured out there has to be a task... At first I wondered how
> xymonnet launched xymon-snmpcollector, then I started running it by
> hand and running tcpdump to see what was being polled
>
> What it looks like what we don't get is mib variable manipulation ala
> devmon... calculated load percentages etc.
>
> Still I think a move in the right direction and it directly supports
> snmp v3
>
>
>
>
> On 5/16/19 10:45 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>> Not sure what that will give you. The OIDs are extracted from the
>> file snmpmibs.conf, and I expect you'll have to populate that with
>> anything you want to monitor.
>>
>> One thing I forgot to mention is that you need to create a task to
>> run the xymon-snmpcollect program every 5 minutes. I created a
>> tasks.d/xymon-snmpcollect.cfg file containing the following:
>>
>> [snmpcollect]
>>         ENVFILE $XYMONHOME/etc/xymonserver.cfg
>>         CMD $XYMONHOME/ext/xymon-snmpcollect --debug
>>         LOGFILE $XYMONSERVERLOGS/xymon-snmpcollect.log
>>         INTERVAL 5m
>>
>> Obviously the --debug flag can be removed.
>>
>> On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 15:26, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> wrote:
>>
>>     Just thinking aloud... Since the build uses net-snmp, it should
>> use the same mibs net-snmp uses... So xymon will know about my
>> SmartUPS and poweredge.
>>
>>     I'm gonna have to study the code some more
>>
>>
>>
>>       On 5/16/19 10:08 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>     > Right you are. DOSNMP is set to "yes" as a result of SNMP being
>> set to 1 (and the Net-SNMP tools being found).
>>     >
>>     >
>>     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 14:42, Bruce Ferrell
>> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> wrote:
>>     >
>>     >     On 5/16/19 9:10 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 13:36, Bruce Ferrell
>> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
>>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>> wrote:
>>     >     >
>>     >     >     Yes, I did Jeremy.  My apologies.
>>     >     >
>>     >     >
>>     >     > No problem.
>>     >     >
>>     >     >     I did figure out I have to export SNMP=1 then
>> configure and rebuild
>>     >     >
>>     >     >
>>     >     > Ah, I didn't know that. Or I forgot that.
>>     >     >
>>     >     > Just looking at the code now - are you sure this isn't
>> "DOSNMP=1"?
>>     >
>>     >
>>     >     The Makefile tests for if  $SNMP=1... At least in 4.3.28
>>     >
>>     >
>>     >     >     What is the tag in the hosts file (if any)?
>>     >     >
>>     >     >
>>     >     > Nothing. The hostnames are found by xymon-snmpcollect in
>> the snmphosts.cfg. You still need the hosts to be in hosts.cfg, but
>> not tags are required.
>>     >
>>     >     > Jeremy
>>     >
>>     >     Thanks again!
>>     >
>>     >
>>     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:41 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>     >     >     > If you meant to say, "Hey Jeremy" then the answer
>> is, that it's all stuff for Xymon.
>>     >     >     >
>>     >     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 11:15, Bruce Ferrell
>> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
>>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>
>>     >     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
>>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>> wrote:
>>     >     >     >
>>     >     >     >     Hey Josh, I saw that before.  Is that stuff
>> that devmon looks at or stuff for xymon.
>>     >     >     >
>>     >     >     >     I'm not at all clear
>>     >     >     >
>>     >     >     >     Thanks in advance
>>     >     >     >
>>     >     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:00 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>     >     >     >>     Xymon already has code for SNMP that works,
>> but isn't documented. I have it working for me, but it required a
>> fair bit or digging to find the right
>>     >     configuration. I've
>>     >     >     >>     posted on this previously; might help:
>> https://lists.xymon.com/archive/2019-March/046191.html
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>     J
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>     On Thu, 16 May 2019 at 19:26, Bruno Manzoni
>> <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>     >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>     >     >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>> wrote:
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>         Thanks you Josh,
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>         Yes I know about devmon (I put my own
>> devmon version which is a try to be a consolidate version)
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>         In fact, I just would like to know if
>> there was another SNMP development (but it seems not as you say it
>> will be merged) inside Xymon . (I am thinking
>>     a way to
>>     >     >     integrate
>>     >     >     >>         SNMP v3, but it do not uses the current
>> SNMP_session perl lib as it is not supported within this lib)?
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>         Regards
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>         Bruno Manzoni
>>     >     >     >>         (Bonomani)
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>
>>     >     >     >>         Le 14.05.2019 à 15:20, Josh Luthman a écrit :
>>     >     >     >>>         You can just use Devmon these days.
>>     >     >     >>>
>>     >     >     >>>         I've seen nothing to suggest the projects
>> will be merged.
>>     >     >     >>>
>>     >     >     >>>         Josh Luthman
>>     >     >     >>>         Office: 937-552-2340
>>     >     >     >>>         Direct: 937-552-2343
>>     >     >     >>>         1100 Wayne St
>>     >     >     >>>         Suite 1337
>>     >     >     >>>         Troy, OH 45373
>>     >     >     >>>
>>     >     >     >>>
>>     >     >     >>>         On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 12:33 PM Bruno
>> Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>     >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>     >     >     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
>> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>> wrote:
>>     >     >     >>>
>>     >     >     >>>             Hello,
>>     >     >     >>>
>>     >     >     >>>             Is there any plan to have SNMP
>> include with a new version of xymon? If
>>     >     >     >>>             yes, what is the current state?
>>     >
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Xymon mailing list
> Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>
> http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon

As a follow on...

using tcpdump and snmpget against the data in the dump shows the counters ARE being retrieved, just not registering.

snmpget -v 2c -c community666name 127.0.0.1 .1.3.6.1.2.1.31.1.1.1.3.4 -Oa

IF-MIB::ifInBroadcastPkts.4 = Counter32: 0

tcpdump was run while hand running xymoln-snmpcollect

On 6/21/19 9:24 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote:

OK, I have bug on this now... I have had off an on for a while now

I have one host in my network NOT being monitored by devmon and I'm trying to use the built in snmp of xymon

snmphosts.cfg:

[hostname.org] version=2 community=community666name ip=127.0.0.1 systemmib ifmib=(*)

snmpmibs.cfg is the file from 4.2.28

[ifmib] keyidx (IF-MIB::ifDescr) keyidx [IF-MIB::ifPhysAddress] keyidx <IF-MIB::ifName> validx {IP-MIB::ipAdEntIfIndex} ifDescr = IF-MIB::ifDescr ifType = IF-MIB::ifType ifMtu = IF-MIB::ifMtu ifSpeed = IF-MIB::ifSpeed ifPhysAddress = IF-MIB::ifPhysAddress ifAdminStatus = IF-MIB::ifAdminStatus ifOperStatus = IF-MIB::ifOperStatus ifLastChange = IF-MIB::ifLastChange ifInOctets = IF-MIB::ifInOctets                                 /rrd:COUNTER ifInUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifInUcastPkts                           /rrd:COUNTER ifInNUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifInNUcastPkts                         /rrd:COUNTER ifInDiscards = IF-MIB::ifInDiscards                             /rrd:COUNTER ifInErrors = IF-MIB::ifInErrors                                 /rrd:COUNTER ifInUnknownProtos = IF-MIB::ifInUnknownProtos                   /rrd:COUNTER ifOutOctets = IF-MIB::ifOutOctets                               /rrd:COUNTER ifOutUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifOutUcastPkts                         /rrd:COUNTER ifOutNUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifOutNUcastPkts                       /rrd:COUNTER ifOutDiscards = IF-MIB::ifOutDiscards                           /rrd:COUNTER ifOutErrors = IF-MIB::ifOutErrors                               /rrd:COUNTER ifOutQLen = IF-MIB::ifOutQLen                                   /rrd:GAUGE

Run by hand as follows:

 ./server/bin/xymon-snmpcollect --debug

26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.952110 Opening file /home/xymon/server/etc/snmphosts.cfg 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953150 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.1' = '"lo"' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953381 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.2' = '"em1"' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953629 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.3' = '"em2"' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953844 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.4' = '"em3"' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954081 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.5' = '"em4"' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954303 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.6' = '"br0"' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954519 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.7' = '"docker0"' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954737 Finished host hostname.org 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966129 No more oids left 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966137 Finished host hostname.org 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966258 Transport setup is: 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966269 xymondportnumber = 1984 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966274 xymonproxyhost = NONE 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966278 xymonproxyport = 0 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966282 Recipient listed as 'XYMON_HOST' 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966287 Standard protocol on port 1984 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966292 Will connect to address XYMON_HOST port 1984 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966463 Connect status is 0 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966551 Sent 7650 bytes 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966588 Closing connection

I get the interface names, but no counters and as a result no RRD entries,and of course, no charting.

What I want it to do is collect the stats for all of the interfaces and then chart them.  I'm suspecting the ifmib definition isn't right if not that, the maybe I need to do something different with snmphosts.cfg

Thoughts?

On 5/17/19 2:04 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

...

For me, yes.

On Fri, 17 May 2019, 17:59 Japheth Cleaver, <cleaver at terabithia.org <mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org>> wrote:

     Other than documentation (obviously), would that be the primary feature set that helps makes this a reasonable thing to integrate in officially?

     -jc

     On 5/16/2019 11:08 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote: > I just figured out there has to be a task... At first I wondered how > xymonnet launched xymon-snmpcollector, then I started running it by > hand and running tcpdump to see what was being polled > > What it looks like what we don't get is mib variable manipulation ala > devmon... calculated load percentages etc. > > Still I think a move in the right direction and it directly supports > snmp v3 > > > > > On 5/16/19 10:45 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >> Not sure what that will give you. The OIDs are extracted from the >> file snmpmibs.conf, and I expect you'll have to populate that with >> anything you want to monitor. >> >> One thing I forgot to mention is that you need to create a task to >> run the xymon-snmpcollect program every 5 minutes. I created a >> tasks.d/xymon-snmpcollect.cfg file containing the following: >> >> [snmpcollect] >>         ENVFILE $XYMONHOME/etc/xymonserver.cfg >>         CMD $XYMONHOME/ext/xymon-snmpcollect --debug >>         LOGFILE $XYMONSERVERLOGS/xymon-snmpcollect.log >>         INTERVAL 5m >> >> Obviously the --debug flag can be removed. >> >> On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 15:26, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> wrote: >> >>     Just thinking aloud... Since the build uses net-snmp, it should >> use the same mibs net-snmp uses... So xymon will know about my >> SmartUPS and poweredge. >> >>     I'm gonna have to study the code some more >> >> >> >>       On 5/16/19 10:08 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >>     > Right you are. DOSNMP is set to "yes" as a result of SNMP being >> set to 1 (and the Net-SNMP tools being found). >>     > >>     > >>     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 14:42, Bruce Ferrell >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> wrote: >>     > >>     >     On 5/16/19 9:10 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >>     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 13:36, Bruce Ferrell >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>> wrote: >>     >     > >>     >     >     Yes, I did Jeremy.  My apologies. >>     >     > >>     >     > >>     >     > No problem. >>     >     > >>     >     >     I did figure out I have to export SNMP=1 then >> configure and rebuild >>     >     > >>     >     > >>     >     > Ah, I didn't know that. Or I forgot that. >>     >     > >>     >     > Just looking at the code now - are you sure this isn't >> "DOSNMP=1"? >>     > >>     > >>     >     The Makefile tests for if  $SNMP=1... At least in 4.3.28 >>     > >>     > >>     >     >     What is the tag in the hosts file (if any)? >>     >     > >>     >     > >>     >     > Nothing. The hostnames are found by xymon-snmpcollect in >> the snmphosts.cfg. You still need the hosts to be in hosts.cfg, but >> not tags are required. >>     > >>     >     > Jeremy >>     > >>     >     Thanks again! >>     > >>     > >>     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:41 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >>     >     >     > If you meant to say, "Hey Jeremy" then the answer >> is, that it's all stuff for Xymon. >>     >     >     > >>     >     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 11:15, Bruce Ferrell >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> >>     >     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>> wrote: >>     >     >     > >>     >     >     >     Hey Josh, I saw that before.  Is that stuff >> that devmon looks at or stuff for xymon. >>     >     >     > >>     >     >     >     I'm not at all clear >>     >     >     > >>     >     >     >     Thanks in advance >>     >     >     > >>     >     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:00 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote: >>     >     >     >>     Xymon already has code for SNMP that works, >> but isn't documented. I have it working for me, but it required a >> fair bit or digging to find the right >>     >     configuration. I've >>     >     >     >>     posted on this previously; might help: >> https://lists.xymon.com/archive/2019-March/046191.html >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>     J >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>     On Thu, 16 May 2019 at 19:26, Bruno Manzoni >> <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >>     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>> >>     >     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>> wrote: >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>         Thanks you Josh, >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>         Yes I know about devmon (I put my own >> devmon version which is a try to be a consolidate version) >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>         In fact, I just would like to know if >> there was another SNMP development (but it seems not as you say it >> will be merged) inside Xymon . (I am thinking >>     a way to >>     >     >     integrate >>     >     >     >>         SNMP v3, but it do not uses the current >> SNMP_session perl lib as it is not supported within this lib)? >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>         Regards >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>         Bruno Manzoni >>     >     >     >>         (Bonomani) >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >> >>     >     >     >>         Le 14.05.2019 à 15:20, Josh Luthman a écrit : >>     >     >     >>>         You can just use Devmon these days. >>     >     >     >>> >>     >     >     >>>         I've seen nothing to suggest the projects >> will be merged. >>     >     >     >>> >>     >     >     >>>         Josh Luthman >>     >     >     >>>         Office: 937-552-2340 >>     >     >     >>>         Direct: 937-552-2343 >>     >     >     >>>         1100 Wayne St >>     >     >     >>>         Suite 1337 >>     >     >     >>>         Troy, OH 45373 >>     >     >     >>> >>     >     >     >>> >>     >     >     >>>         On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 12:33 PM Bruno >> Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >>     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>> >>     >     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>> wrote: >>     >     >     >>> >>     >     >     >>>  Hello, >>     >     >     >>> >>     >     >     >>>             Is there any plan to have SNMP >> include with a new version of xymon? If >>     >     >     >>>  yes, what is the current state? >>     > >> > > _______________________________________________ > Xymon mailing list > Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com> > http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon

---

Xymon mailing list Xymon at xymon.com http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon

---

Xymon mailing list Xymon at xymon.com http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon

Hi Jeremy,

Yes, you're correct, the snmpmibs.cfg is an excerpt. It does have the [systemmib] section and that part executes correctly (or seems to) so I left that out.  The debug output does have the opening snmpmibs part.  That shows all of the sections and it's rather lengthy,  I did not note errors there.

I've now corrected the error you noted and commented out everything I'm not using in snmpmibs.cfg (should have done that before)...

And I'm now getting columns in the display and RRDs!

I. AM. STOKED!

Now to get the charts working.  Once I get that working (some year) I'll write my notes up and submit them as semi-documentation for the feature.

Thanks for the help!

On 6/22/19 7:01 AM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

Bruce

Firstly, just to make sure the snmpmibs.cfg you showed is only an excerpt, right? Your snmphosts.cfg file references systemmib and so snmpmibs.cfg must have a [systemmib] section. Your debug output should be saying "Opening file /home/xymon/server/etc/snmpmibs.cfg" but it's not, so I'm hoping you're providing an abridged version of the output.

Secondly, I believe there's an error in the snmpmibs.cfg file in the [hrstorage] section. I don't know if this will affect your situation given that your snmphosts.cfg does not reference hrstorage, and your manual run of xymon-snmpcollect does not show any errors along these lines.

Anyhow, for the record, I believe this line:

        keyidx [(HOST-RESOURCES-MIB::hrStorageType]

is supposed to be:

        keyidx [HOST-RESOURCES-MIB::hrStorageType]

In the first form, the opening parenthesis has no matching closing parenthesis and I believe it's an extra character that should be removed.

Having said all this, your debug output seems to be sending something into Xymon without any problem reported, so the problem may be further down the chain.

The xymon-snmpcollect process creates a supplemental client data message to report its findings to Xymon, so have a look at the client data for your host and see if there's an [ifmib] section and that it looks reasonable.

The SNMP client data is parsed by xymond - so check xymond.log for errors.

From the parsed client data, xymond creates a status message of the form "status hostname.mibname color timestamp <summary>" such as "status hostname.org.ifmib green Sat Jun 22 21:20:19 2019 bla bla". You could use xymond_channel to tap into the status message stream and confirm that there's a status message being generated. You should also see an "ifmib" test appear on the Xymon page containing the hostname.

If a status message is generated, it gets picked up by xymond_rrd. If the message is malformed, you might find a message explaining why in the rrd_status.log file. The status message has a particular format so that the RRD parser can turn the text and numbers into RRD data. It should have "Interval=N" (N is likely 300), and "ActiveIP=<IP address>". Then it will have a series of VAR=VAL lines, possibly in sections denoted by square brackets. In the case of the ifmib, the sections are the interface names, and the VAR=VAL lines contain things like ifOctets=NNNNN and ifOperStatus=up (and all the things in the [ifmib] section of the snmpmibs.cfg file.

Cheers Jeremy

On Sat, 22 Jun 2019 at 14:38, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> wrote:

As a follow on...

using tcpdump and snmpget against the data in the dump shows the
counters ARE being retrieved, just not registering.

snmpget -v 2c -c community666name 127.0.0.1
.1.3.6.1.2.1.31.1.1.1.3.4 -Oa

IF-MIB::ifInBroadcastPkts.4 = Counter32: 0

tcpdump was run while hand running xymoln-snmpcollect



On 6/21/19 9:24 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote:
> OK, I have bug on this now... I have had off an on for a while now
>
> I have one host in my network NOT being monitored by devmon and
I'm trying to use the built in snmp of xymon
>
> snmphosts.cfg:
>
> [hostname.org <http://hostname.org>]
>   version=2
>   community=community666name
>   ip=127.0.0.1
>   systemmib
>   ifmib=(*)
>
> snmpmibs.cfg is the file from 4.2.28
>
> [ifmib]
>         keyidx (IF-MIB::ifDescr)
>         keyidx [IF-MIB::ifPhysAddress]
>         keyidx <IF-MIB::ifName>
>         validx {IP-MIB::ipAdEntIfIndex}
>         ifDescr = IF-MIB::ifDescr
>         ifType = IF-MIB::ifType
>         ifMtu = IF-MIB::ifMtu
>         ifSpeed = IF-MIB::ifSpeed
>         ifPhysAddress = IF-MIB::ifPhysAddress
>         ifAdminStatus = IF-MIB::ifAdminStatus
>         ifOperStatus = IF-MIB::ifOperStatus
>         ifLastChange = IF-MIB::ifLastChange
>         ifInOctets = IF-MIB::ifInOctets /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifInUcastPkts =
IF-MIB::ifInUcastPkts                           /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifInNUcastPkts =
IF-MIB::ifInNUcastPkts                         /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifInDiscards =
IF-MIB::ifInDiscards                             /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifInErrors = IF-MIB::ifInErrors /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifInUnknownProtos =
IF-MIB::ifInUnknownProtos                   /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifOutOctets =
IF-MIB::ifOutOctets                               /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifOutUcastPkts =
IF-MIB::ifOutUcastPkts                         /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifOutNUcastPkts =
IF-MIB::ifOutNUcastPkts                       /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifOutDiscards =
IF-MIB::ifOutDiscards                           /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifOutErrors =
IF-MIB::ifOutErrors                               /rrd:COUNTER
>         ifOutQLen =
IF-MIB::ifOutQLen                                   /rrd:GAUGE
>
> Run by hand as follows:
>
>  ./server/bin/xymon-snmpcollect --debug
>
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.952110 Opening file
/home/xymon/server/etc/snmphosts.cfg
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953150 Got key-oid
'.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.1' = '"lo"'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953381 Got key-oid
'.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.2' = '"em1"'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953629 Got key-oid
'.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.3' = '"em2"'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953844 Got key-oid
'.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.4' = '"em3"'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954081 Got key-oid
'.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.5' = '"em4"'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954303 Got key-oid
'.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.6' = '"br0"'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954519 Got key-oid
'.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.7' = '"docker0"'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954737 Finished host hostname.org
<http://hostname.org>
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966129 No more oids left
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966137 Finished host hostname.org
<http://hostname.org>
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966258 Transport setup is:
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966269 xymondportnumber = 1984
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966274 xymonproxyhost = NONE
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966278 xymonproxyport = 0
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966282 Recipient listed as 'XYMON_HOST'
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966287 Standard protocol on port 1984
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966292 Will connect to address
XYMON_HOST port 1984
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966463 Connect status is 0
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966551 Sent 7650 bytes
> 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966588 Closing connection
>
> I get the interface names, but no counters and as a result no
RRD entries,and of course, no charting.
>
> What I want it to do is collect the stats for all of the
interfaces and then chart them.  I'm suspecting the ifmib
definition isn't right if not that, the maybe I need to do
> something different with snmphosts.cfg
>
> Thoughts?
>
>
>
> On 5/17/19 2:04 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>> For me, yes.
>>
>>
>> On Fri, 17 May 2019, 17:59 Japheth Cleaver,
<cleaver at terabithia.org <mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org>
<mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org <mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org>>>
wrote:
>>
>>      Other than documentation (obviously), would that be the
primary feature
>>      set that helps makes this a reasonable thing to integrate
in officially?
>>
>>      -jc
>>
>>      On 5/16/2019 11:08 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote:
>>      > I just figured out there has to be a task... At first I
wondered how
>>      > xymonnet launched xymon-snmpcollector, then I started
running it by
>>      > hand and running tcpdump to see what was being polled
>>      >
>>      > What it looks like what we don't get is mib variable
manipulation ala
>>      > devmon... calculated load percentages etc.
>>      >
>>      > Still I think a move in the right direction and it
directly supports
>>      > snmp v3
>>      >
>>      >
>>      >
>>      >
>>      > On 5/16/19 10:45 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>      >> Not sure what that will give you. The OIDs are
extracted from the
>>      >> file snmpmibs.conf, and I expect you'll have to
populate that with
>>      >> anything you want to monitor.
>>      >>
>>      >> One thing I forgot to mention is that you need to
create a task to
>>      >> run the xymon-snmpcollect program every 5 minutes. I
created a
>>      >> tasks.d/xymon-snmpcollect.cfg file containing the
following:
>>      >>
>>      >> [snmpcollect]
>>      >>         ENVFILE $XYMONHOME/etc/xymonserver.cfg
>>      >>         CMD $XYMONHOME/ext/xymon-snmpcollect --debug
>>      >>         LOGFILE $XYMONSERVERLOGS/xymon-snmpcollect.log
>>      >>         INTERVAL 5m
>>      >>
>>      >> Obviously the --debug flag can be removed.
>>      >>
>>      >> On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 15:26, Bruce Ferrell
<bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> wrote:
>>      >>
>>      >>     Just thinking aloud... Since the build uses
net-snmp, it should
>>      >> use the same mibs net-snmp uses... So xymon will know
about my
>>      >> SmartUPS and poweredge.
>>      >>
>>      >>     I'm gonna have to study the code some more
>>      >>
>>      >>
>>      >>
>>      >>       On 5/16/19 10:08 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>      >>     > Right you are. DOSNMP is set to "yes" as a result
of SNMP being
>>      >> set to 1 (and the Net-SNMP tools being found).
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 14:42, Bruce Ferrell
>>      >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>> wrote:
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >     On 5/16/19 9:10 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>      >>     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 13:36, Bruce Ferrell
>>      >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>
>>      >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>> wrote:
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     >     Yes, I did Jeremy.  My apologies.
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     > No problem.
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     >     I did figure out I have to export
SNMP=1 then
>>      >> configure and rebuild
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     > Ah, I didn't know that. Or I forgot that.
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     > Just looking at the code now - are you sure
this isn't
>>      >> "DOSNMP=1"?
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >     The Makefile tests for if $SNMP=1... At least
in 4.3.28
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >     >     What is the tag in the hosts file (if any)?
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     >
>>      >>     >     > Nothing. The hostnames are found by
xymon-snmpcollect in
>>      >> the snmphosts.cfg. You still need the hosts to be in
hosts.cfg, but
>>      >> not tags are required.
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >     > Jeremy
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >     Thanks again!
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >
>>      >>     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:41 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
>>      >>     >     >     > If you meant to say, "Hey Jeremy"
then the answer
>>      >> is, that it's all stuff for Xymon.
>>      >>     >     >     >
>>      >>     >     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 11:15, Bruce
Ferrell
>>      >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>
>>      >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>
>>      >>     >     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>>      >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
>>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
<mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>>> wrote:
>>      >>     >     >     >
>>      >>     >     >     >     Hey Josh, I saw that before.  Is
that stuff
>>      >> that devmon looks at or stuff for xymon.
>>      >>     >     >     >
>>      >>     >     >     >     I'm not at all clear
>>      >>     >     >     >
>>      >>     >     >     >     Thanks in advance
>>      >>     >     >     >
>>      >>     >     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:00 PM, Jeremy
Laidman wrote:
>>      >>     >     >     >>  Xymon already has code for SNMP
that works,
>>      >> but isn't documented. I have it working for me, but it
required a
>>      >> fair bit or digging to find the right
>>      >>     >     configuration. I've
>>      >>     >     >     >>  posted on this previously; might help:
>>      >> https://lists.xymon.com/archive/2019-March/046191.html
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>     J
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>     On Thu, 16 May 2019 at 19:26,
Bruno Manzoni
>>      >> <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >>     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
>>      >>     >     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>>> wrote:
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>  Thanks you Josh,
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>  Yes I know about devmon (I put my own
>>      >> devmon version which is a try to be a consolidate version)
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>  In fact, I just would like to know if
>>      >> there was another SNMP development (but it seems not as
you say it
>>      >> will be merged) inside Xymon . (I am thinking
>>      >>     a way to
>>      >>     >     >     integrate
>>      >>     >     >     >>  SNMP v3, but it do not uses the current
>>      >> SNMP_session perl lib as it is not supported within
this lib)?
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>  Regards
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>  Bruno Manzoni
>>      >>     >     >     >>  (Bonomani)
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>
>>      >>     >     >     >>  Le 14.05.2019 à 15:20, Josh Luthman
a écrit :
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    You can just use Devmon these days.
>>      >>     >     >     >>>
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    I've seen nothing to suggest the
projects
>>      >> will be merged.
>>      >>     >     >     >>>
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    Josh Luthman
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    Office: 937-552-2340
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    Direct: 937-552-2343
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    1100 Wayne St
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    Suite 1337
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    Troy, OH 45373
>>      >>     >     >     >>>
>>      >>     >     >     >>>
>>      >>     >     >     >>>    On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 12:33 PM
Bruno
>>      >> Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >>     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
>>      >>     >     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
>>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
<mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>>> wrote:
>>      >>     >     >     >>>
>>      >>     >     >     >>>  Hello,
>>      >>     >     >     >>>
>>      >>     >     >     >>>        Is there any plan to have SNMP
>>      >> include with a new version of xymon? If
>>      >>     >     >     >>>  yes, what is the current state?
>>      >>     >
>>      >>
>>      >
>>      > _______________________________________________
>>      > Xymon mailing list
>>      > Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>
<mailto:Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>>
>>      > http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon
>>
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Xymon mailing list
> Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>
> http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Xymon mailing list
> Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>
> http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon
>

I actually can't say what made the columns not show.  I suspect xymon-snmpcollect wasn't sending a complete message.

I've been working on graphs and on inspecting the rrds that now exist, I see there is a format, but no data collected in them.  No errors, just NAN.  The I noticed the data format is not compatible with the built in NCV processor, so I either have to modify the code for the snmp collector to send NCV format or  post process the data into the rrds

On 6/22/19 8:54 AM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

Great news.

Do you think the typo in the snmpmibs.cfg was causing no RRD files to be generated?

On Sun, 23 Jun 2019 at 01:47, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> wrote:

Hi Jeremy,

Yes, you're correct, the snmpmibs.cfg is an excerpt. It does have the [systemmib] section and that part executes correctly (or seems to) so I left that out.  The debug output
does have the opening snmpmibs part.  That shows all of the sections and it's rather lengthy,  I did not note errors there.

I've now corrected the error you noted and commented out everything I'm not using in snmpmibs.cfg (should have done that before)...

And I'm now getting columns in the display and RRDs!

I. AM. STOKED!

Now to get the charts working.  Once I get that working (some year) I'll write my notes up and submit them as semi-documentation for the feature.

Thanks for the help!




On 6/22/19 7:01 AM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:

...

Bruce

Firstly, just to make sure the snmpmibs.cfg you showed is only an excerpt, right? Your snmphosts.cfg file references systemmib and so snmpmibs.cfg must have a [systemmib]
section. Your debug output should be saying "Opening file /home/xymon/server/etc/snmpmibs.cfg" but it's not, so I'm hoping you're providing an abridged version of the output.

Secondly, I believe there's an error in the snmpmibs.cfg file in the [hrstorage] section. I don't know if this will affect your situation given that your snmphosts.cfg does
not reference hrstorage, and your manual run of xymon-snmpcollect does not show any errors along these lines.

Anyhow, for the record, I believe this line:

        keyidx [(HOST-RESOURCES-MIB::hrStorageType]

is supposed to be:

        keyidx [HOST-RESOURCES-MIB::hrStorageType]

In the first form, the opening parenthesis has no matching closing parenthesis and I believe it's an extra character that should be removed.

Having said all this, your debug output seems to be sending something into Xymon without any problem reported, so the problem may be further down the chain.

The xymon-snmpcollect process creates a supplemental client data message to report its findings to Xymon, so have a look at the client data for your host and see if there's
an [ifmib] section and that it looks reasonable.

The SNMP client data is parsed by xymond - so check xymond.log for errors.

From the parsed client data, xymond creates a status message of the form "status hostname.mibname color timestamp <summary>" such as "status hostname.org.ifmib green Sat Jun
22 21:20:19 2019 bla bla". You could use xymond_channel to tap into the status message stream and confirm that there's a status message being generated. You should also see
an "ifmib" test appear on the Xymon page containing the hostname.

If a status message is generated, it gets picked up by xymond_rrd. If the message is malformed, you might find a message explaining why in the rrd_status.log file. The
status message has a particular format so that the RRD parser can turn the text and numbers into RRD data. It should have "Interval=N" (N is likely 300), and "ActiveIP=<IP
address>". Then it will have a series of VAR=VAL lines, possibly in sections denoted by square brackets. In the case of the ifmib, the sections are the interface names, and
the VAR=VAL lines contain things like ifOctets=NNNNN and ifOperStatus=up (and all the things in the [ifmib] section of the snmpmibs.cfg file.

Cheers
Jeremy

On Sat, 22 Jun 2019 at 14:38, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> wrote:

    As a follow on...

    using tcpdump and snmpget against the data in the dump shows the counters ARE being retrieved, just not registering.

    snmpget -v 2c -c community666name 127.0.0.1 .1.3.6.1.2.1.31.1.1.1.3.4 -Oa

    IF-MIB::ifInBroadcastPkts.4 = Counter32: 0

    tcpdump was run while hand running xymoln-snmpcollect



    On 6/21/19 9:24 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote:
    > OK, I have bug on this now... I have had off an on for a while now
    >
    > I have one host in my network NOT being monitored by devmon and I'm trying to use the built in snmp of xymon
    >
    > snmphosts.cfg:
    >
    > [hostname.org <http://hostname.org>]
    >   version=2
    >   community=community666name
    >   ip=127.0.0.1
    >   systemmib
    >   ifmib=(*)
    >
    > snmpmibs.cfg is the file from 4.2.28
    >
    > [ifmib]
    >         keyidx (IF-MIB::ifDescr)
    >         keyidx [IF-MIB::ifPhysAddress]
    >         keyidx <IF-MIB::ifName>
    >         validx {IP-MIB::ipAdEntIfIndex}
    >         ifDescr = IF-MIB::ifDescr
    >         ifType = IF-MIB::ifType
    >         ifMtu = IF-MIB::ifMtu
    >         ifSpeed = IF-MIB::ifSpeed
    >         ifPhysAddress = IF-MIB::ifPhysAddress
    >         ifAdminStatus = IF-MIB::ifAdminStatus
    >         ifOperStatus = IF-MIB::ifOperStatus
    >         ifLastChange = IF-MIB::ifLastChange
    >         ifInOctets = IF-MIB::ifInOctets /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifInUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifInUcastPkts /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifInNUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifInNUcastPkts /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifInDiscards = IF-MIB::ifInDiscards /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifInErrors = IF-MIB::ifInErrors /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifInUnknownProtos = IF-MIB::ifInUnknownProtos /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifOutOctets = IF-MIB::ifOutOctets /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifOutUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifOutUcastPkts /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifOutNUcastPkts = IF-MIB::ifOutNUcastPkts /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifOutDiscards = IF-MIB::ifOutDiscards /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifOutErrors = IF-MIB::ifOutErrors /rrd:COUNTER
    >         ifOutQLen = IF-MIB::ifOutQLen /rrd:GAUGE
    >
    > Run by hand as follows:
    >
    >  ./server/bin/xymon-snmpcollect --debug
    >
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.952110 Opening file /home/xymon/server/etc/snmphosts.cfg
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953150 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.1' = '"lo"'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953381 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.2' = '"em1"'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953629 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.3' = '"em2"'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.953844 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.4' = '"em3"'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954081 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.5' = '"em4"'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954303 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.6' = '"br0"'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954519 Got key-oid '.1.3.6.1.2.1.2.2.1.2.7' = '"docker0"'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.954737 Finished host hostname.org <http://hostname.org>
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966129 No more oids left
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966137 Finished host hostname.org <http://hostname.org>
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966258 Transport setup is:
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966269 xymondportnumber = 1984
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966274 xymonproxyhost = NONE
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966278 xymonproxyport = 0
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966282 Recipient listed as 'XYMON_HOST'
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966287 Standard protocol on port 1984
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966292 Will connect to address XYMON_HOST port 1984
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966463 Connect status is 0
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966551 Sent 7650 bytes
    > 26951 2019-06-21 21:12:36.966588 Closing connection
    >
    > I get the interface names, but no counters and as a result no RRD entries,and of course, no charting.
    >
    > What I want it to do is collect the stats for all of the interfaces and then chart them.  I'm suspecting the ifmib definition isn't right if not that, the maybe I need
    to do
    > something different with snmphosts.cfg
    >
    > Thoughts?
    >
    >
    >
    > On 5/17/19 2:04 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
    >> For me, yes.
    >>
    >>
    >> On Fri, 17 May 2019, 17:59 Japheth Cleaver, <cleaver at terabithia.org <mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org> <mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org <mailto:cleaver at terabithia.org>>>
    wrote:
    >>
    >>      Other than documentation (obviously), would that be the primary feature
    >>      set that helps makes this a reasonable thing to integrate in officially?
    >>
    >>      -jc
    >>
    >>      On 5/16/2019 11:08 PM, Bruce Ferrell wrote:
    >>      > I just figured out there has to be a task... At first I wondered how
    >>      > xymonnet launched xymon-snmpcollector, then I started running it by
    >>      > hand and running tcpdump to see what was being polled
    >>      >
    >>      > What it looks like what we don't get is mib variable manipulation ala
    >>      > devmon... calculated load percentages etc.
    >>      >
    >>      > Still I think a move in the right direction and it directly supports
    >>      > snmp v3
    >>      >
    >>      >
    >>      >
    >>      >
    >>      > On 5/16/19 10:45 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
    >>      >> Not sure what that will give you. The OIDs are extracted from the
    >>      >> file snmpmibs.conf, and I expect you'll have to populate that with
    >>      >> anything you want to monitor.
    >>      >>
    >>      >> One thing I forgot to mention is that you need to create a task to
    >>      >> run the xymon-snmpcollect program every 5 minutes. I created a
    >>      >> tasks.d/xymon-snmpcollect.cfg file containing the following:
    >>      >>
    >>      >> [snmpcollect]
    >>      >>         ENVFILE $XYMONHOME/etc/xymonserver.cfg
    >>      >>         CMD $XYMONHOME/ext/xymon-snmpcollect --debug
    >>      >>         LOGFILE $XYMONSERVERLOGS/xymon-snmpcollect.log
    >>      >>         INTERVAL 5m
    >>      >>
    >>      >> Obviously the --debug flag can be removed.
    >>      >>
    >>      >> On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 15:26, Bruce Ferrell <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> wrote:
    >>      >>
    >>      >>     Just thinking aloud... Since the build uses net-snmp, it should
    >>      >> use the same mibs net-snmp uses... So xymon will know about my
    >>      >> SmartUPS and poweredge.
    >>      >>
    >>      >>     I'm gonna have to study the code some more
    >>      >>
    >>      >>
    >>      >>
    >>      >>       On 5/16/19 10:08 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
    >>      >>     > Right you are. DOSNMP is set to "yes" as a result of SNMP being
    >>      >> set to 1 (and the Net-SNMP tools being found).
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 14:42, Bruce Ferrell
    >>      >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>> wrote:
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >     On 5/16/19 9:10 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
    >>      >>     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 13:36, Bruce Ferrell
    >>      >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>
    >>      >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>> wrote:
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >     Yes, I did Jeremy.  My apologies.
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     > No problem.
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >     I did figure out I have to export SNMP=1 then
    >>      >> configure and rebuild
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     > Ah, I didn't know that. Or I forgot that.
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     > Just looking at the code now - are you sure this isn't
    >>      >> "DOSNMP=1"?
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >     The Makefile tests for if  $SNMP=1... At least in 4.3.28
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >     >     What is the tag in the hosts file (if any)?
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >
    >>      >>     >     > Nothing. The hostnames are found by xymon-snmpcollect in
    >>      >> the snmphosts.cfg. You still need the hosts to be in hosts.cfg, but
    >>      >> not tags are required.
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >     > Jeremy
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >     Thanks again!
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>     >     >     On 5/16/19 6:41 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
    >>      >>     >     >     > If you meant to say, "Hey Jeremy" then the answer
    >>      >> is, that it's all stuff for Xymon.
    >>      >>     >     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >     > On Fri, 17 May 2019 at 11:15, Bruce Ferrell
    >>      >> <bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>
    >>      >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>
    >>      >>     >     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
    >>      >>     <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org
    <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org> <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org <mailto:bferrell at baywinds.org>>>>>>> wrote:
    >>      >>     >     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >     >  Hey Josh, I saw that before.  Is that stuff
    >>      >> that devmon looks at or stuff for xymon.
    >>      >>     >     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >     >  I'm not at all clear
    >>      >>     >     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >     >  Thanks in advance
    >>      >>     >     >     >
    >>      >>     >     >     >  On 5/16/19 6:00 PM, Jeremy Laidman wrote:
    >>      >>     >     >     >>    Xymon already has code for SNMP that works,
    >>      >> but isn't documented. I have it working for me, but it required a
    >>      >> fair bit or digging to find the right
    >>      >>     >     configuration. I've
    >>      >>     >     >     >>    posted on this previously; might help:
    >>      >> https://lists.xymon.com/archive/2019-March/046191.html
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>    J
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>    On Thu, 16 May 2019 at 19:26, Bruno Manzoni
    >>      >> <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >>     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
    >>      >>     >     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
    <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>>> wrote:
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        Thanks you Josh,
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        Yes I know about devmon (I put my own
    >>      >> devmon version which is a try to be a consolidate version)
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        In fact, I just would like to know if
    >>      >> there was another SNMP development (but it seems not as you say it
    >>      >> will be merged) inside Xymon . (I am thinking
    >>      >>     a way to
    >>      >>     >     >     integrate
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        SNMP v3, but it do not uses the current
    >>      >> SNMP_session perl lib as it is not supported within this lib)?
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        Regards
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        Bruno Manzoni
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        (Bonomani)
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>
    >>      >>     >     >     >>        Le 14.05.2019 à 15:20, Josh Luthman a écrit :
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         You can just use Devmon these days.
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         I've seen nothing to suggest the projects
    >>      >> will be merged.
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         Josh Luthman
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         Office: 937-552-2340
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         Direct: 937-552-2343
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         1100 Wayne St
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         Suite 1337
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         Troy, OH 45373
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>         On Fri, May 10, 2019 at 12:33 PM Bruno
    >>      >> Manzoni <bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >>     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >>     <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>
    >>      >>     >     >  <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch
    <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>
    >>      >> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch> <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch <mailto:bruno.manzoni at ubi-network.ch>>>>>>> wrote:
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>  Hello,
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>             Is there any plan to have SNMP
    >>      >> include with a new version of xymon? If
    >>      >>     >     >  >>>  yes, what is the current state?
    >>      >>     >
    >>      >>
    >>      >
    >>      > _______________________________________________
    >>      > Xymon mailing list
    >>      > Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com> <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>>
    >>      > http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon
    >>
    >>
    >
    > _______________________________________________
    > Xymon mailing list
    > Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>
    > http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon
    >
    >
    > _______________________________________________
    > Xymon mailing list
    > Xymon at xymon.com <mailto:Xymon at xymon.com>
    > http://lists.xymon.com/mailman/listinfo/xymon
    >

when t